Home Page
Directory
Computer Usage Paper
Information
Literacy Paper
Harry Potter Webquest
Nebraska
Scavenger Hunt
Internet
Timeline
Human
Body Webquest
Harry
Potter Scavenger Hunt
Dr
Seuss Scavenger Hunt
Anne
of Green Gables Webquest
Recommended
Books
|
Computer Usage in the Elementary Classroom
Erin E. McCabe
Instructional Technology Competencies
Curriculum 959 Sec 001 SPRING 2002
University of Nebraska-Lincoln
This
paper focuses on the current usage of computers in elementary classrooms
and the problems associated with computer usage in the elementary classroom.
The paper includes information on how to make educators computer literate
and integrate computers into the elementary curriculum. Although the intent
of this paper is to have this computer integration in the elementary classroom,
it will address the concerns of those who feel computers do not belong
in the elementary classroom. This paper is supported by research on education
and computer integration from the U.S. Department of Education.
"The
Office of Technology Assessment (1995b) estimates that the number of computers
in K-12 schools increased by 300,000 to 400,000 a year during the past decade.
The total number of computers in schools is estimated to reach 5.8 million
during 1995, one for every nine students." (Abdal Haqq, 1995) "Over
90% of schools are wired (connected to the Internet), and over one-third
of teachers have Internet access in their classrooms, which they and their
students use frequently." (Goldman et als, 1999) Most teachers and
students use word processing programs. (Abdal Haqq, 1995) We also see some
teachers using spreadsheets, simulations, CAD systems and multimedia software.
(Abdal Haqq, 1995) However despite these numbers computer-based technologies
are not being fully exploited by the majority of teachers. (Abdal Haqq,
1995) Relatively few teachers routinely use computer-based technologies
for instructional purposes and when computers are used, they are generally
used for low-level tasks such as drills and word processing. (Abdal Haqq,
1995) Computers are not being integrated across the K-12 curriculum. (Abdal
Haqq, 1995) The issue of integrating computers into the elementary classroom
is an impassioned one. The issue of having computers in elementary schools
is a heated one. These issues stir up the emotions of teachers, administrators,
and parents. They are emotional issues because they involve more that just
a machine. They involve how children are taught, how children learn, and
how schools are run. The issue of computers in elementary schools has been
debated since computers first appeared in elementary schools.
Computers first started being used in elementary schools in 1965 when the
Elementary and Secondary Education Act brought new money into schools for
technology. (CSULB, 1996) Mainframes and minicomputers were put into place
in some schools, but most were used for administration or for school counseling.
(CSULB, 1996) Computer usage in elementary schools continued to spread in
1975 when some Apple 1 PCs were donated to schools and schools adopted mainframes
and minicomputers. (CSULB, 1996) In 1981, IBM introduced its personal computer
(PC) for use in the home, office and schools. (LaMorte et al, 1994) Competition
in the area of personal computers made the personal computer more affordable
and increased the use of personal computers in homes, offices, and schools.
(OLTCL, 1996) The number of personal computers in use more than doubled
from 2 million in 1981 to 5.5 million in 1982. (LaMorte et al, 1994) Part
of this increase of computer in school was brought about by pressure on
schools. (OLTCL, 1996) This pressure resulted in computers finding their
way into many schools for the wrong reasons. (OLTCL, 1996) Unsure of what
to do with the computers and how to use them, many teachers ignored them
or left it to the technology teachers to teach the students to use them.
(OLTCL, 1996) A few teachers did take an interest in computers but mostly
people felt that computers were the domain of scientists, mathematicians,
and business. (OLTCL, 1996) The year 1981 also brought about the development
of the first drill and practice programs for personal computers. (CSULB,
1996) In direct competition with IBM's PC was Apple's Macintosh line, introduced
in 1984. (CSULB, 1996) Notable for its user-friendly design, the Macintosh
offered an operating system that allowed users to move screen icons instead
of typing instructions. (LaMorte et al, 1994) Users controlled the screen
cursor using a mouse, a device that mimicked the movement of one's hand
on the computer screen. (LaMorte et al, 1994) In 1983 the Apple II computer
finds widespread acceptance in education because PCs better fit the teacher
/manager model of instructional delivery. (CSULB, 1996) Since 1983, schools
have increased the numbers of computers and have created computer labs.
(OLTCL, 1996)
Many schools had hired computing specialist teachers to provide leadership
in the area of educational computing. (OLTCL, 1996) Computers had also extended
out of the mathematics department into other parts of the curriculum like
the language department where word processing was included in the curriculum.
(OLTCL, 1996) Database and spreadsheet software were also being used in
other areas of the curriculum. (OLTCL, 1996) By 1984, 31 states used 13,000
PCs for career guidance, but there were still relatively few computers in
classrooms. (CSULB, 1996) Computer-based tutorials and learning games were
also being developed by commercial software manufacturers in 1984. (CSULB,
1996) By 1986 K-8 schools were buying mostly Apple II and Macintosh computers.(CSULB,
1996) By 1994 most U.S. classrooms now had at least one PC available for
instructional delivery, but not all teachers had access to a computer for
instructional preparation. (CSULB, 1996) Many thought that computers would
revolutionize education, that computer-based teaching and learning would
become the savior of education and the solution to falling test scores.
(Hardin et al, 2000) "This has never really happened." (Hardin
et al, 2000) The Internet did not revolutionize education either, all it
did was provide an opportunity to expand learning options for teachers and
students who were fortunate enough to have Internet access, a few computers,
and appropriate guidance on usage. (Hardin et al, 2000) The revolution began
to take place in 1993. "In November 1993, the National Center for Supercomputing
Applications (NCSA) released Mosaic, the first World Wide Web browser for
all three computing platforms (UNIX, PC, and Macintosh)." (Hardin et
al, 2000) "Soon after its introduction, NCSA Mosaic caused a 100,000-fold
increase in WWW NSFnet backbone traffic and brought in millions of users,
thus creating a market for the dozens of commercial browsers that subsequently
have been introduced." (Hardin et al, 2000) Spyglass, Netscape, and
Microsoft all have produced browsers and Web technology, and scores of companies
have jumped into the Web market. (Hardin et al, 2000) "On the server
side, NCSA WWW server software is used on roughly 50 percent of the installed
base of WWW servers on the open Internet and about 70 percent of those in
the .EDU domain (which consists of educational institutions)." (Hardin
et al, 2000). It is clear that the Web is now a permanent fixture. The Internet
has become the World Wide Web, and Mosaic has allowed anyone with the ability
to use a computer and a mouse to go out onto the Web and easily and quickly
locate multimedia information. (Hardin et al, 2000) Text, images, sound,
and video come to the desktop and are used by students from the kindergarten
through Ph.D. levels. (Hardin et al, 2000) It is a revolution because teachers
cannot choose to ignore the information provided by the web the way they
can ignore computers. (Hardin et al, 2000) "This 'computer revolution'
in education involves far more than simply finding new ways to help kids
learn. (Healy, 1998) It challenges some of our most deeply held beliefs
on about how children should be raised and educated. (Healy, 1998)
Educating children about computers or making them computer literate began
when computers first appeared in classrooms. In the past computer literacy
involved the following areas: teaching children to use the computer to calculate,
draw, or write, having the computer provide instruction to the children
and teaching children to program computers. (Geisert et al, 1984) The following
is what computer literacy was defined as in the past. The Association of
Computing Machinery (ACM) gave the following set of teacher set of competencies,
developed in 1980 as what teachers should meet to be considered computer
literate:
--Read
and write simple computer programs
--Use
educational computer programs and documentation
--Use
computer hardware terminology
--Recognize
the limits of solving educational problems using the computer
--Locate
information on computing in education
--Discuss
the historical development of computer technology for education
--Discuss
the moral and human impact issues relating to societal and educational
use of computers (Taylor and others 1980). (Geisert et al, 1984)
This kind of knowledge is just a very minimal practical knowledge of computers.
(Papert, 1993)
This kind of knowledge is still included in today's definition of computer
literacy but more skills are needed to be considered computer literate.
Teaching computer literacy means teaching students to use the computer
and making sure they use it effectively. Effective use of computers is
defined as use of a computer system to accomplish well defined goals with
less expense than before in terms of time and money. (Bristow, 1997) If
using a computer means that it takes more time or money to achieve your
goals than the computer is not being used effectively. (Bristow, 1997)
In the next section I will discuss the current usage of computers in elementary
classrooms.
A computer has many purposes in the classroom today. In a classroom the
computer serves as a classroom tool and as a subject of instruction. (Geisert
et al, 1984) As a classroom tool, computers are being used for research,
word processing, art, and administrative purposes. Students use the Internet
and CD-ROM programs for research. (Learning Solutions, 1998) During word
processing, elementary school children can use computers as tools to create
their own text and to practice writing and reading. (ERIC, 1983)
Word processing programs encourage children to experiment with language
as well as to record their own writing. (ERIC, 1983) For art, the computer
can be used to draw pictures or designs. (ERIC, 1983) Children can learn
to create their own designs and pictures. (ERIC, 1983) Children gain an
increased understanding of design, composition, and use of color when
using computers for art. (ERIC, 1983) "Although not part of children's
direct involvement with computers, administrative uses of computers free
educators from routine record keeping to spend more time in instructional
activities and at the same time help them to develop computer literacy."
(ERIC, 1983) Computers in schools are frequently used for accounting,
reports, word processing, attendance or personnel records, and budget
preparation or management. (ERIC, 1983)
As a subject of instruction, computers are used to teach the students.
Computer assisted instruction (CAI) is when the computer is used as a
tutor and concepts, information, or skills normally presented through
conventional teaching methods are taught by the computer. (ERIC, 1983)
Text based applications including drill and practice applications are
forms of computer assisted instruction. (ERIC, 1983) Computer programming
is also being taught to elementary students. (ERIC, 1983) Computer programming
helps to promote computer literacy and prepare children for a computer-oriented
future. (ERIC, 1983) Computer programming requires students to analyze
tasks, pose alternative solutions to problems, understand how to sequence
instructions, and use logic. (ERIC, 1983) These examples are just a few
ways that computers are being used to supplement instruction. In the next
section, I will look at how using computers to supplement instruction
benefits elementary children and how computers can benefit teachers.
The benefits to children depend upon the kind of computer experiences
they have and the access they have to computers. (ERIC, 1983) Standardized
tests however do not show the benefit of computer usage. (Healy, 1998)
Standardized tests measure only a limited span of skills, broader measures
are needed. (Healy, 1998) Computers can help improve motor skills, enhance
mathematical thinking, increase creativity, improve scores on tests of
critical thinking and problem solving, and increase scores on standardized
language assessments. (Haugland, 2000) Computers enhance children's self-concept,
and increase levels of spoken communication and cooperation. (Haugland,
2000) Computers also enhance collaborative learning, alternative assessment,
and individualized learning. (NSBA, 2002) Computers are also beneficial
in helping to meet the learning needs of all students. Howard Gardner
has stated that humans have seven or more multiple intelligences: Verbal/Linguistic,
Logical/Mathematical, Visual/Spatial, Musical, Interpersonal, and Intrapersonal.
(NSBA, 2002) Multimedia can be used to address these intelligences. (NSBA,
2002) Verbal/Linguistic intelligence, the ability to think, communicate,
and create through words both in speech and in writing can be aided by
computer software that allows students to write and illustrate their own
stories. (NSBA, 2002) Word processing software also stimulates learners
to interact more closely with their work. (NSBA, 2002) Verbal/Linguistic
intelligence is also benefited by telecommunications programs that allow
students to communicate with other students in writing. (NSBA, 2002) Logical/mathematical
intelligence, the ability to memorize and perform mathematical operations,
think mathematically, logically, and analytically and to apply that understanding
to problem solving can be benefited by multimedia products that graphically
illustrate physics concepts. (NSBA, 2002) It is also benefited by programs
that provide challenging visual/spatial tasks which develop mathematical
and logical thinking. (NSBA, 2002)
Visual/spatial intelligence, the ability to understand the world through
what we see and imagine and to express ideas through graphic arts can
be benefited by paint programs, databases of artwork, desktop publishing,
and Internet sites to museums and virtual tours. (NSBA, 2002) Bodily/kinesthetic
intelligence, the ability to learn through physical coordination and dexterity
and the ability to express oneself through physical activities can be
benefited by educational games which challenge fine motor coordination
while helping to develop logical thinking skills. (NSBA, 2002) It can
also be benefited by electronic field trips that allow the students to
interact electronically with a scientist. (NSBA, 2002) Musical intelligence,
the ability to understand, appreciate, perform, and create music by voice,
instruments or dance can be benefited by Musical Instrument Digital Interface
which makes it possible to make music on an electronic keyboard, that
can be made to sound like any instrument. (NSBA, 2002) It is also benefited
by interactive presentations of renowned classical music. (NSBA, 2002)
Interpersonal intelligence, the ability to work cooperatively with other
people and to apply a variety of skills to communicate with and understand
others can be benefited by cooperative learning activities. (NSBA, 2002)
It can also be benefited by electronic networks that link the students
with people around the world. (NSBA, 2002) Intrapersonal intelligence
the ability to understand, bring to consciousness, and express one's own
inner world of thoughts and emotions can be benefited by multimedia that
turns the classroom into centers of student-directed inquiry. (NSBA, 2002)
It can also be benefited by technology that supports electronic records
and multimedia portfolios of student work. (NSBA, 2002) Computers also
allow students to work in visual-spatial intelligence rather than the
traditional visual-analytic intelligence. (Healy, 1998)
Image processing allows these students to release their creativity by
working through visual and kinesthetic rather than verbal intelligence.
(Healy, 1998) A student who has the chance to work through visual and
kinesthetic channels may do better in the new technology fields than those
limited to linguistic and linear forms of reasoning. (Healy, 1998) Computers
are also beneficial to students with learning disabilities. Assistive
or remedial technology harnesses the power of computers to help students
with learning differences. (Healy, 1998) "Children with cerebral
palsy can move a cursor on a computer screen by moving their eyes, the
computer measures movements with small electrodes placed near the eyes."
(Healy, 1998) Tutorials help those with language impairments and spell-checkers
have already benefited poor spellers and nonfluent writers. (Healy, 1998)
Computers can also be used in many other ways to help those with physical
and mental impairments. For education professionals, computers allow networking
which creates a professional bond between teachers and administrators
and ends isolation. (NSBA, 2002) If we move beyond test scores we see
that computers can be beneficial to children and to teachers in the classroom
if used effectively. Teachers just need to teach students how to use them
effectively which means teaching computer literacy.
Computer literacy today involves mastering a set of core competencies.
(Stoll, 1999) It does not mean that a student has to know everything about
the computer but they should know some basics. Some of these basics include
being able to use a word processor, manipulate a spreadsheet, know what
a database does, be able to use e-mail, and know how to browse the World
Wide Web. (Stoll, 1999) Browsing the World Wide Web involves being able
to make an informed judgment about what you find on-line. The basics also
include being able to describe computer hardware and software functions
and perform basic computer operations like using the keyboard and mouse,
turning the computer on and off, opening computer applications, minimizing
and closing windows, and managing files and folders. (Dover, 2002) Once
they have mastered the basics, students should learn how to use the computer
to conduct library and Internet research, to create and edit reports and
presentations, and to communicate with others. (Dover, 2002) If children
are computer literate, integration of computers into the elementary classroom
becomes easier. In the next section I will look at the instructor's role
in a computer integrated classroom.
A teacher in a computer-integrated classroom has four roles: Instructor,
Coach, Model, and Critic. (Davis et al, 1994) As Instructor the teacher
guides the children through new software and encourages exploration of
the material. (Davis et al, 1994) The teacher is the Instructor when children
are becoming familiar with the technology. (Davis et al, 1994) The teacher
moves into the role of coach as the students gain more experience. (Davis
et al, 1994) As Coach the teacher provides guidance and support and ensures
appropriate behavior. (Davis et al, 1994) The teacher acts as Model and
Critic during both periods. (Davis et al, 1994) The teacher is the Model
by showing the students that they use computers for learning. (Davis et
al, 1994) Students will be more likely to use the computer if they see
the teacher using it. (Davis et al, 1994) Teachers are the critic by selecting
software that enhances their student's development and learning. (Davis
et al, 1994) These examples are roles that a teacher must take on if they
are going to have a computer integrated classroom. However, these are
roles that some teachers are not always willing to accept and these are
roles that some adults do not think teachers should accept. I believe
that computers should be used in elementary classrooms and that elementary
students should be taught to use computers but there are others who feel
that computers do not belong in an elementary classrooms and have concerns
about teaching children to use computers. In the following sections, I
will present some of the concerns adults have about having computers in
elementary classroom.
One concern adults have about having computers in the elementary classroom
is the Internet. The Internet poses new challenges for parents because
children can interact with anyone online from the home, school or library
and any user, anywhere, can post any information, including materials
that are inaccurate, misleading and inappropriate for children. (Kehoe,
et al, 1997) Many adults are concerned about some of dangers found on
the Internet. Adults are concerned about children being lured away by
predators that they have chatted with online. (Kehoe et al, 1997) They
worry about their children having access to pornographic materials as
well as materials from hate groups and cults. (Kehoe et al, 1997) Adults
worry that computers are becoming an open door to their worst nightmares.
(Kehoe et al, 1997) Adults are also concerned about the security of their
computer system. Viruses, worms, and Trojan horses can all be damaging
to a computers' system and some of these can be delivered by using the
Internet.
Another reason adults have concerns about having computers in elementary
classrooms is that they feel that current computer teachings are not meeting
educational standards. Teachers, parents, administrators, and lawmakers
are all looking for accountability. (Healy, 1998) School accountability
is a dominant theme in education reform today. (Allen, 1994) Accountability
means different things to different people, (ranging from 'back to basics'
objective testing to equalization of school financing. (Allen, 1994)
"Yet at the core of the accountability movement lies a common concern:
the need for agreed-upon, easily understandable, readily adaptable measures
of how well our schools are doing, and how student achievement in the
U.S. today, from district to district and state to state, compares with
foreign competitors and our own historical record." (Allen, 1994)
In Education there are five types of accountability: political accountability,
legal accountability, bureaucratic accountability, professional accountability,
and market accountability. (Darling-Hammond et al, 1989) Political accountability
involves evaluating the performance of legislators and school board members.
Legal Accountability means making sure schools uphold the law. (Darling-Hammond
et al, 1989) Bureaucratic Accountability takes place when district and
state education offices produce rules and regulations intended to ensure
that schooling takes place according to set standards. (Darling-Hammond
et al, 1989) Professional Accountability is when teachers and other school
staff must acquire specialized knowledge, pass certification exams, and
uphold professional standards of practice. Market Accountability is when
parents and students evaluate schools and choose the courses or schools
they believe are most appropriate. (Darling-Hammond et al, 1989) The type
of accountability that adults are focusing on most today is bureaucratic
accountability. The drive for bureaucratic accountability and school standards
began nationally in 1989 as a result of the Education Summit, when then-President
George Bush met with the nation's governors, developed national education
goals, and established the National Educational Goals Panel which reports
on the progress toward six national education goals. (Allen, 1994) The
Bush administration also helped fund efforts by private organizations
to set standards in the core curricular areas. (Allen, 1994) This drive
for standards continued with President Clinton who encouraged states to
adopt national standards by subject matter, and encouraged the development
and use of national standards for workplace skills. (Allen, 1994) Clinton
also created the National Education Standards and Improvement Council
(NESIC), which would oversee existing efforts to develop content and performance
standards by subject area and the Opportunity-to-Learn (OTL) standards
which were intended to provide measures of school performance by which
the taxpaying public could evaluate the quality of education provided
in their community. (Allen, 1994) Besides providing measures of school
performance the OTL also helped further the theory that any monetary rewards
for schools should be based on achievement and monetary punishment should
follow poor performance. (Allen, 1994) This theory is why standards and
accountability are such a great concern to schools. They fear that if
they do not measure up to public scrutiny they will lose funding. (Allen,
1994) Money is not the only concern of schools. They want to know who
will be creating and enforcing the standards, will it be the federal government
or the state government, and how the comparisons to determine school performance
will be made. (Allen, 1994) Schools want to know if the comparisons will
be school to school, classroom to classroom, or district to district and
what standards of comparisons are going to be used. (Allen, 1994) They
are also concerned about what instrument will be used to measure school
accountability. (Darling-Hammond et al, 1989) Traditionally standardized
tests are used to evaluate performance but testing does not ensure that
schools will teach students well or responsibly, or that students will
learn what their parents and the public want them to know. (Darling-Hammond
et al, 1989) Standardized testing is also not capable of measuring certain
areas. (Darling-Hammond et al, 1989) Computers is one of these areas.
It is impossible to assess computer skills using a standardized test.
This statement is one argument for not having computers in schools. If
the tests don't show that students are benefiting from or learning anything
from computers people believe that they shouldn't be in the schools. Another
justification to their argument that computers are not meeting educational
standards is some of the computer software for children. (Healy, 1998)
"Edutainment" is a term meant to describe electronically sugar-coated
learning." (Healy, 1998) "It is found most often on CD-ROMS
and is mainly produced by entertainment companies, not educators."
(Healy, 1998) Besides feeling that computers and their software are not
cognitively stimulating, many adults feel that computers and their software
are having a negative effect on children, both cognitively and physically.
I will address both of these concerns in the next section.
Computers do affect children and the concern that they are negatively
affecting children is a large one. (Healy, 1998) The affect of computers
on children physically and mentally needs to be addressed. One part of
a child's body that is being affected by computers is their eyes. "Visual
strain is the number one problem of frequent computer users." (Healy,
1998) "Studies estimate that anywhere from half to 90% of computer
users suffer from visual deterioration." Children are also suffering
from postural and skeletal problems. (Healy, 1998) One postural problem
reported is called "video wrist". (Healy, 1998) It resembles
carpal tunnel syndrome and includes numbness, pain, and sometimes tendonitis
in the wrists and hands. (Healy, 1998) Physical fitness is also another
health concern of adults. (Healy, 1998) In the United States, children
are getting less fit. (Healy, 1998) At least one in five children in the
United States is overweight. (AOA, 2002) "Approximately 13 percent
of children (age 6 to 11) and 14 percent of adolescents (age 12 to 19)
are considered overweight, a figure which has doubled in 30 years."
(AOA, 2002) Excess weight in childhood and adolescence has been found
to predict obesity in adulthood. (AOA, 2002) Children with obesity, age
10 to 13, are reported to have a 70% likelihood of obesity persisting
into adult years. (AOA, 2002) The tendency toward obesity is fostered
by a lack of physical activity. (AOA, 2002) Besides being a factor in
obesity, physical inactivity is a major risk factor for developing coronary
artery disease. (AHA, 2002) It also increases the risk of stroke and other
major risk factors as high blood pressure, a low level of HDL ("good")
cholesterol and diabetes. (AHA, 2002) Children who are inactive are likely
to become inactive adults. (AHA, 2002)
The cognitive areas that are affected by computers are attention, motivation,
and metacognition. (Healy, 1998) In the area of attention, children need
to be able to control the brain's focus, organize a response and stay
involved. (Healy, 1998) Many software programs select the focus and organize
the responses for the child and then sustain the interest by using lots
of stimulus. (Healy, 1998) Motivation is important for long range success.
(Healy, 1998) According to the Encarta World English dictionary motivation
is the biological, emotional, cognitive, or social forces that activate
and direct behavior. (Encarta, 2001) Motivation is needed for a student
to be productive and to stay on task even when the task is not an exciting
one. (Healy, 1998) Computers reduce motivation because they give students
the impression that learning is supposed to be a game with splashy special
effects. (Healy, 1998) When the subject matter isn't a game where they
blow up things or doesn't have flashing lights to attract their attention,
students tend to tune out and give up. Metacognition is knowledge about
your own thoughts and the factors that influence your thinking. (Encarta,
2001) During metacognition, people monitor what they are doing, evaluate
what they have done, and develop strategies to use in similar situations.
(Healy, 1998) People are thinking about thinking. (Blakey et al, 1990)
They know what they know and what they don't know. (Blakey et al, 1990)
The basic metacognitive strategies are connecting new information to former
knowledge, selecting thinking strategies, and planning, monitoring, and
evaluating thinking processes. (Blakey et al, 1990) Computer software
impairs metacognition because it does not always foster the construction
of meaningful mental representations instead it presents material and
expects the student to absorb it. (Moreno et als, 2001) Computer software
programs also allow students to simply use trial and error to determine
an answer and do not make them plan out a strategy to use to determine
the answer or evaluate why their answer was wrong. (Blakey et al, 1990)
Computer software can also impair metacognition by limiting self-directed
learning which takes places during metacognition. (Blakey et al, 1990)
Computer software can sometimes be too structured, controlling how long
the program runs and only have students typing information in certain
boxes or clicking on icons during the activity rather than having the
students estimate the time needed to complete a task, organize materials,
and schedule procedures necessary to complete the task. (Blakey et al,
1990) Besides worrying about how computers affect children, adults worry
about the cost of computers and the cost to make classrooms ready for
computer integration. This fear is an issue that I will cover in the next
section.
Hardware and the design and shape of school are a concern to adults because
they determine how much it is going to cost them to get their schools
and classrooms ready for computer integration. If the cost is too high,
schools are deterred from integrating computers into their classrooms.
"The U.S. General Accounting Office recently estimated that half
of the country's schools have wiring too outdated to support Internet."
(Healy, 1998) "Few classrooms have telephone lines and wires must
be put in wall mounted tubes or through concrete walls." (Healy,
1998) If the schools have asbestos things become even more difficult.
(Healy, 1998) Besides having wiring in need of repair the schools themselves
are often in need of repair. "Approximately 60 percent of U.S. schools
are in need of repair." (Healy, 1998) School designs are a problem
because more space is needed for workstations and projects. (Healy, 1998)
"Effective deployment of computers in schools takes up to 25% more
space than is usually available in traditional classrooms." (Healy,
1998) Hardware and the design and shape of schools can all be a deterrent
to computer integration if it costs too much to make them ready for computer
integration. In the following sections, I will talk about other deterrents
to computer integration.
One deterrent to computer integration in elementary classrooms is the
teacher. One reason the teachers are a deterrent to computer integration
is that they have not been educated on how to integrate computers into
their curriculum. In 1999, the barriers to the use of computer and the
Internet for instruction most reported by public school teachers were
not enough computers, lack of release time for teachers to learn how to
use computers or the Internet, and lack of time in schedule for students
to use computers in class. (NCES, 2000) The most common reasons given
for the low level of computer use in schools are limited access to equipment
and lack of training. (Abdal Haqq, 1995) Both new and veteran teachers
feel inadequately prepared to use computers in their classroom. (Abdal
Haqq, 1995) "In a survey of recent graduates, the Office of Technology
Assessment (1995b) found that while more than half reported being prepared
to utilize drill and practice, tutorials, games, word processing, and
publishing applications; less than 10% felt competent to use multimedia
and presentation packages, electronic network collaboration capabilities,
or problem-solving applications." (Abdal Haqq, 1995) One reason teachers
are unprepared to deal with the technology is their pre-service teacher
education. (Abdal Haqq, 1995) During teacher training educators do not
sufficiently model appropriate use of computers for instructional purposes
during courses or field experiences. (Abdal, Haqq, 1995) Teacher programs
do not incorporate technology across the curriculum. (Abdal Haqq, 1995)
Instruction that is provided to pre-service teachers tends to focus more
on computer assisted instruction and word processing and less on exposure
to and practice with electronic networks, integrated media and problem-solving
applications. (Abdal Haqq, 1995) Obstacles to including more technology
in teacher education programs include limited availability of equipment;
lack of faculty training; no clear expectation that faculty will incorporate
technology in academic activities; lack of funds; lack of time to develop
a class in using equipment and software; doubts about the validity of
using some of the newer technologies for instruction; lack of technical
support; lack of appropriate materials, particularly integrated media
materials suitable for teacher education instruction; and an absence of
clear programmatic goals for the teacher education program as a whole.
(Abdal Haqq, 1995) Another reason that teachers are unprepared to deal
with the technology is that there has not been time to train them. (Healy,
1998) Most teachers are already overwhelmed by their regular duties. (Healy,
1998) They do not have time to be trained on how to prepare a first-rate
instructional program for a whole new medium. (Healy, 1998)
Another way that teachers become a deterrent to computer integration is
their fear. Most teachers fear the day that their students know more about
computers than they do. (Papert, 1993) Teachers fear that they will lose
control if their students learn that they do not have all answers. (Papert,
1993) Teachers should not fear this however. They should welcome the opportunity
of having students take on the role of teachers or the opportunity to
learn at the same time as their students. Teachers and students learning
together can be a rewarding experience. (Papert, 1993) Learning in use
also allows students to learn in their own way. (Papert, 1993) Educators
also fear that they are being replaced by technology experts. (Healy,
1998) They think that people who are experts in technology but who know
nothing about education are starting to run the show. (Healy, 1998) They
are worried that education is becoming some sort of training school for
the high tech world. (Healy, 1998)
Another deterrent to computer integration in elementary schools is school
policy. Schools with their fixed curriculum, standardized tests, and other
materials tend to reduce learning to a series of technical acts and the
teacher to a technician. (Papert, 1993)) In the early 1980's when there
were few computers in school, the teachers who had them would use them
across the curriculum. (Papert, 1993) But when the number of computers
increased the school, administration stepped in and put the computers
all together in one room under the control of a computer teacher and gave
computers their own curriculum. (Papert, 1993) Schools saw computers as
an instrument of change and were threatened. (Papert, 1993) They neutralized
its effectiveness by assimilating it in to the existing school structure
instead of adapting their school structure so the computers could be used
effectively. (Papert, 1993) Schools are set up as a hierarchy. (Papert,
1993) The students are supervised by the teachers. (Papert, 1993) The
teachers are supervised by curriculum coordinators and department heads,
they are supervised by principals and everyone is supervised by the superintendent.
(Papert, 1993) "Under this hierarchical system the teacher is in
control and decides how the skill will be taught; the learner simply has
to obey the instructions." (Papert, 1993) Computers are a threat
to this system because they allow children to be autonomous. (Papert,
1993) They offer children an alternative way to learn which challenges
current methods of instruction. (Papert, 1993) Computers challenge the
fixed curriculum. (Papert, 1993) Computers also alter what we teach and
how we teach it. (Papert, 1993) Teachers, schools, and the technology
itself can all be deterrents to computer integration. In the following
sections I will discuss how to overcome some of the deterrents to computer
integration.
To begin integrating computers into the elementary classroom we need to
overcome the problems created by student-computer ratios. One way to overcome
the problem of having only one computer in the classroom is to connect
a television or computer projection system to the computer. (Learning
Solutions, 1998) This set-up will help make use of the computer as a presentation
device and will eliminate the problem of having the entire class huddle
around the computer trying to see the teacher demonstrate an activity.
(Learning Solutions, 1998) A computer projection system will also be useful
for whole class writing activities. (TRC, 2002) Another way of overcoming
the problem of having only one computer in the classroom is cooperative
groups. (Learning Solutions, 1998) If a rotation schedule is posted next
to the computer, each group will have an assigned time during the day.
(Learning Solutions, 1998) "In a typical day, five or six twenty-minute
sessions can be accommodated in this way." (Learning Solutions, 1998)
When using small groups each person should be assigned a role to complete
and they should evaluate their contribution each day. (TRC, 2002) The
following roles could be used: Researcher - locates information and helpful
resources; Organizer - uses the organizational chart to determine a logical
sequence for informative details; Grammarian - Checks for proper mechanics;
Computer Engineer - Uses the keyboard and selects proper font. spacing,
bullets, etc.; and Composer - Checks for transitions and sentence variety.
(TRC, 2002) In a classroom that employs learning centers the computer
could be used as a research station, data collection station or publication
center. (Learning Solutions, 1998)The classroom computer can also be a
blackboard where teachers post daily announcements, quizzes, grade sheets,
and student presentations. (Tan, 1998) It can be used to interface with
other technologies. (Tan, 1998) It can act as a secretary helping teachers
create handouts, worksheets, puzzles, report cards, and letters home as
well as help record attendance. It can also become a message board where
teachers post messages and topic stimulators. (Tan, 1998) Student-Computer
ratio is not the only concern that needs to be looked at when trying to
integrate computers into the elementary classroom. Many other concerns
also exist, one being Internet security and safety.
The Internet can be a safe place if children are not on by themselves.
(Kehoe et al, 1997) Parents and teachers must choose what they want children
to see, read, or hear. It is best if the child is using the Internet actively
with the child. In a class with 15 to 20 students, this is impossible
for a teacher to do, so an extra safety net may be needed. (Kehoe et al,
1997) Types of protective software are available that can be used to protect
the students. (Kehoe et al, 1997) These software can track the time used
for a specific application, be configured to only allow the use of specific
programs, and block selected sites and resources. (Kehoe et al, 1997)
Types of software can also keep track of the child's travels while using
the Internet. (Kehoe et al, 1997) Children also need to be given guidelines
on using the Internet. "Most schools require that a student and a
student's parent or guardian sign the schools Acceptable Use Policy (AUP)
in order to allow access to the school's online resources." (Kehoe
et al, 1997) An AUP is intended to protect the student and the school
from problems that can occur during use of the Internet. (Kehoe et al,
1997) It is advisable that you make sure the students understand all the
rules and regulations involved in the AUP. The following are recommended
guidelines for Internet use.
1. Do not give out any personal information about yourself or anyone else.
2. Make sure what you publish contains no names, photos, or personal information.
3. No chat room visits.
4. Observe time limits. (Healy, 1998)
A recommended time limit for Internet usage is twenty minutes. This should
be enough time for students to collect the information they need and prevent
wandering. (Healy, 1998) Teachers can also protect students by previewing
sites and selecting those relevant to the assignment and by teaching them
good research strategies. (Healy, 1998) Children should also be taught
that being careful when you talk to strangers is important to remember
when they are outside and when they are on the Internet. (Healy, 1998)
Teachers and parents need to show students how to critically analyze information
that they find on the World Wide Web. (Healy, 1998) They can help students
do this by giving them the names of reputable sites when they are doing
research. Teachers and parents can also teach students about the types
of sites that are most likely to have accurate information like sites
for educational and governmental institutions as well as sites for educational
networks like PBS or the Discovery Channel.
Besides protecting the children, schools need to protect their computer
systems. They can do this by avoiding high risk sources. (University of
Regina, 2002) "Viruses and other dangerous programs are most often
found on public domain software or from pirated copies of commercial software
placed on electronic bulletin boards." (University of Regina, 2002)
Schools should also use a virus detection program. If a virus is detected,
schools should try to prevent its spread by notifying the network administrator,
using the disinfectant function of the virus program to try and restore
the infected program to its original state or erasing the program and
reinstalling it from original disks after the system has been cleared
of viruses. (University of Regina, 2002) Virus detection programs not
only detect viruses that may be in your system, they can also scan email
messages for viruses to make sure your system does not get infected through
an email. Virus detection programs can be very helpful and should be used
by schools but they are not the only software programs that should be
used by schools. Schools should also use educational software programs
and with these programs come more concerns that need to be overcome.
As mentioned prior in this paper many feel that computers are not meeting
educational standards and students are not learning much from educational
software. I will begin to address the concern about accountability by
stating that each area of the education system is accountable for different
things. The state and the district central office must each be accountable
for the policies they adopt. (Darling-Hammond et al, 1989) They must assume
responsibility for equity in the distribution of school resources, and
for creating processes that keep them responsive to the needs and concerns
of parents, students, and school-level staff. (Darling-Hammond et al,
1989) The school must be accountable for adopting policies that reflect
professional knowledge and the interests of children. (Darling-Hammond
et al, 1989) Schools need to hire and support competent and committed
staff. They need to provide opportunities for faculty to meet with each
other and with parents to evaluate and discuss their teaching and students'
progress. (Darling-Hammond et al, 1989) Teachers and other staff must
be accountable for identifying and meeting the needs of individual students
responsibly and knowledgeably based on professional standards of practice,
for evaluating how well their practices are accomplishing this goal, for
seeking new knowledge and information, and continually revising their
strategies to better meet the needs of students. (Darling-Hammond et al,
1989) In assessing student performance students need to use more than
just standardized tests. (Darling-Hammond et al, 1989) Student demonstrations,
portfolio assessment, student products and digital portfolios can all
be used to assess student learning and show parents and other adults that
educational outcomes are being met. (NSBA, 2002) To make sure students
needs are being met teachers need to make sure that students understand
what they are doing with the computer or what is being done by the computer
and can explain the process or format they have used for projects. (Healy,
1998) Teachers should also make sure they can reflect upon what they have
learned. (Healy, 1998) When using the computer in the classroom teachers
should fit the activity to the students' level of maturation and cognitive
development. (Healy, 1998) Teachers should also fit the activity to students'
interests and experiences. (Healy, 1998)
To address the concerns about educational software, teachers should select
the best software for each of the different types of software. Current
uses of computers can be divided into four software categories: applications
software to accomplish routine tasks more efficiently; programs for teaching
basic skills; communication software; and laser disc or computer simulations
designed to foster content knowledge, thinking, or problem solving. (Healy,
1998) "Applications are the closest thing we have to using the computer
as a tool." (Healy, 1998) "They can support highly structured
drill and practice activities or more active learning." (Healy, 1998)
Examples of application software include word processing, database, spreadsheets,
classroom and school management aids, CD-ROM encyclopedias, and multimedia
authoring tools. (Healy, 1998) Programs that teach basic skills include
drill and practice programs, integrated learning systems, and cognitive
tutors. (Healy, 1998) Communication software includes software that connects
us to the Internet or World Wide Web and distance learning software. (Healy,
1998) In order to use computers effectively and to make sure children
are actually learning something teachers need to choose appropriate software.
When choosing software teachers first need to determine what they wish
to accomplish. (Healy, 1998) They should make sure they consider their
students age and abilities when doing this. (Healy, 1998) Teachers should
try to preview the software before they purchase to determine if it is
appropriate for the classroom, does not contain stereotypical images and
is equitable to all genders and races. (Healy, 1998) If teachers are unable
to preview the software they should read software reviews from reputable
journals. (Healy, 1998) The software teachers choose should have varying
levels of difficulty and easy to understand directions. (Healy, 1998)
Teachers should avoid software where students are just clicking on icons
or are rewarded with games. (Healy, 1998) The software should be more
than just skill and drill, it should allow students to be creative and
it should allow the teacher to create activities that allow students to
move beyond the computer. (Healy, 1998) The best educational software
programs extend problem solving skills. (Healy, 1998) Good software programs
intersperse quick drills with conceptual learning. (Healy, 1998) They
coach the child on why an answer was incorrect rather than just telling
him the correct answer. (Healy, 1998) They also give the child the pleasure
at succeeding at a task rather than rewarding them with games or silliness.
(Healy, 1998)
Good software must also be used so that children are gaining knowledge
other than how to move the character on the screen and accomplishing tasks
other than just clicking the mouse. (Healy, 1998) If all the child is
doing is clicking the mouse than money is being wasted (Healy, 1998) To
ensure learning takes place during software use teachers or parents should
accompany the child while he or she is exploring the software and talk
to them about what is going on in the program. (Healy, 1998) Teachers
and parents should also make sure that the child is not just clicking
the mouse impulsively. (Healy, 1998) If the child is doing this, then
the mouse should be removed and the child should be taught to explain
why he is going to perform a task during a program before he does it.
(Healy, 1998) Children should also be taught to plan out their actions
before they use the computer. (Healy, 1998) If the child is using the
computer to draw or write a story, they should have a story or picture
idea in their head and be able to describe it to a parent or teacher.
(Healy, 1998)
Besides
addressing the concerns about software and educational standards, schools
need to address the concerns about the physical and mental effects of
computers. To keep students eyes healthy schools need to eliminate sources
of light and glare. (Healy, 1998) They should also use desk lamps whenever
possible and try not to use computers in rooms with fluorescent lamps.
(Healy, 1998) Teachers also need to have children take eye breaks. (Healy,
1998) "Students should take fifteen minutes off for every hour of
computer use." (Healy, 1998) Teachers should also remind children
to blink. (Healy, 1998) Computer users tend look at the screen to long
without blinking. (Healy, 1998) Postural and skeletal problems can be
prevented by encouraging students to use good posture when working at
the computer. (Healy, 1998) "Workstations should also be adjustable
for different sized children." (Healy, 1998) A posture cushion to
support the lower back could help too. (Healy, 1998) Obesity in children
can be countered by giving students time for physical exercise especially
time for outdoor exercise. (Healy, 1998) Physical activity produces overall
physical, psychological and social benefits. Physical activity helps with
weight control, reducing blood pressure, raising HDL ("good")
cholesterol, reducing the risk of diabetes and some kinds of cancer.(AHA,
2002) The American Heart Association recommends that all children age
5 and older should participate in at least 30 minutes of enjoyable, moderate-intensity
activities every day. (AHA, 2002) They should also perform at least 30
minutes of vigorous physical activities at least 3-4 days each week to
achieve and maintain a good level of cardio respiratory (heart and lung)
fitness. (AHA, 2002) "Physical activity is vital for health, good
sleep patterns, dissipation of excess energy, and socialization."
(Healy, 1998)
To make sure that computers are used to benefit children cognitively.
Teachers can avoid selecting software that is filled with blinking or
flashing lights and a lot of noise going on which hinder the development
in attention span and give them the impression that learning is supposed
to entertain them. (Healy, 1998) Teachers can use computers to boost motivation
by letting the child be an active agent in the learning rather than a
button pusher. (Healy, 1998) Teachers need to stay away from software
programs that give rewards for completing tasks and choose ones that encourage
creative thinking.(Healy, 1998) They should also give students corrective
feedback and support the notion that learning itself is interesting and
one does not need to be rewarded to do it. (Healy, 1998) Teachers can
also improve motivation by insisting that children take responsibility
for their actions. (Healy, 1998) It's important for teachers to hold the
students accountable for all of their classroom behavior, whether they
are using the computer or not. (Kehoe et al, 1997) Metacognition can be
improved by using software that has a social agency environment, software
that has an animated character that talks to the learner and interacts
with the learner by having the student respond and then giving feedback
to these responses. (Moreno et als, 2001) "The social agency environment
includes an element of discovery, unlike the text-based environments."
(Moreno et als, 2001) Discovery-based learning environments facilitate
constructivist learning through creative problem solving experiences.
"Constructivist learning is defined as meaningful learning in which
a learner actively builds a mental model of the system they are to learn,
as is best evaluated by problem solving transfer in which the learner
must use what has been learned to solve challenging new problems."
(Moreno et als, 2001) The constructivist view also has roots in theories
of motivation. (Moreno et als, 2001) These programs aid constructivist
learning by scaffolding the child's learning and guiding them through
a problem solving experience. (Moreno et als, 2001) They also aid constructivist
learning by getting students personally involved in the task. (Moreno
et als, 2001). Animated characters help personalize the learning task
and students feel a connection with these characters which promotes interest
in the task which fosters constructivist learning. (Moreno et als, 2001)
However, not all software with animated characters should be used in a
classroom. (Moreno ET ALS, 2001) Some software programs with entertaining
illustrations or auditory materials actually hurt students' retention
and transfer of the core material. (Moreno et als, 2001) After schools
have addressed the concerns of adults, they need to look at the concerns
and problems found with in the school that can deter computer integration.
One of these problems is the education of the educators.
Educating educators means preparing educators to use the technology and
addressing their fears and concerns. Efforts are being made to better
prepare teachers to use instructional technology. (Abdal Haqq, 1995) While
there is room for improvement in technology utilization schools, colleges,
and departments of education are moving forward and in some cases, leading
the way. (Beck et al, 1998) "New unit standards (effective fall 1995)
developed by the National Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education
include guidelines that address content and pedagogical studies for initial
teacher preparation, faculty qualifications, resources for teaching."
(Abdal Haqq) "Examples from the second category can be found in the
recent Office of Technology Assessment (1995a) report, Teachers &
Technology: Making the Connection. (Abdal Haqq, 1995) "Programs where
technology support has become an integral part of a revised teacher education
program are characterized by a required course for pre-service teachers,
which teach them how to use instructional technologies and exposure to
technology-rich K-12 classrooms."(Abdal Haqq, 1995) "At 40%
of these programs students are required during the on-campus part of their
program to design and deliver instruction incorporating various technologies."
(Beck et al, 1998) "Students at another 50% of these programs are
required to demonstrate the use of at least one technology during their
on-campus classes." (Beck et al, 1998) "At 28% of these programs
students are required to design and deliver instruction that incorporates
various technologies during the student teaching experience." (Beck
et al, 1998) Almost all institutions provide students accessibility to
basic word processing, spreadsheet, and presentation programs. (Beck et
al, 1998) "Students at 57% of these institutions have access to advanced
electronic technologies." (Beck et al, 1998) Trends for using technology
in on-campus classes are positive but the use of technology does drop
off during student teaching. (Beck et al, 1998) Schools of education have
been encouraged to continue to identify and implement technology-rich
instructional strategies within required preparation course work. (Beck
et al, 1998)
Faculty use of technology has also improved. "Faculty members at
45% of the schools, colleges, or departments of education responded that
they regularly use computers, televisions, and VCRs as interactive instructional
tools during class periods." (Beck et al, 1998) "Faculty members
at another 53% of these institutions occasionally use some technology
to present information during class periods." (Beck et al, 1998)
"In addition, 81% of schools, colleges, or departments of education
require students to use computer applications to complete assignments."
(Beck et al, 1998) Current unit standards reflect recommendations from
the International Society for Technology in Education (ISTE). (Beck et
al, 1998) New standards for bringing technology into teacher education
programs and a vision for what skills and understandings graduating students
should bring into the classroom will be part of the revisions. (Beck et
al, 1998) As states require more capability with technology through licensing
and certification standards, schools of education will alter programs
to produce new teachers able to meet those requirements. (Beck et al,
1998)
Teachers who are already in the classroom should also receive training.
"Teachers who are already in the classroom may be at five different
stages of technology integration (novice, apprentice, instructor, coach,
and expert)." (TLTI, 1999) After the teacher's skill level is identified
administrators, teachers, and the educational technologist can determine
what support and resources are needed to move on to the next stage. (TLTI,
1999) "Individual tutoring, peer coaching, collaboration, networking,
and mentoring have been used successfully over extended periods to help
teachers at all levels of technology implementation develop technology
applications that promote engaged learning." (TLTI, 1999) Teachers
should also have the opportunity to participate in the type of workshops,
seminars, and online professional communities that will help them use
technology effectively. (TLTI, 1999) Time for independent study, experimentation,
and curriculum development also is important. (TLTI, 1999) Technical support
is also a must. (Healy, 1998) "Teachers cannot be expected to teach
and to repair machines." (Healy, 1998)
Teachers' fears of technology need to be respected and listened to before
trying to solve them. Teachers could be voicing real concerns that haven't
occurred to most technology people. (Kehoe et al, 1997) Patience and willingness
to listen will make relations between supporters of technology and those
opposed easier. (Kehoe et al, 1997) All though not all of their concerns
can be solved, their fear of losing control can. Teachers' fears of losing
control can be addressed by assuring them that they are not.
Even though there are computers in the classrooms teachers still have
to maintain control. Teachers still have to make rules and enforce them.
(Kehoe et al, 1997) They have to teach students to accept responsibility
for their behavior and hold them accountable for their actions. (Kehoe
et al, 1997) Teachers are not the only deterrent to computer integration
found in schools, sometimes schools themselves are a deterrent to computer
integration.
To first deal with these problems we have to acknowledge that "successful
integration of classroom technology implies changes of huge magnitude
in educational philosophy, classroom management, and curricular goals."
(Healy, 1998) For the technologies to be used successfully teachers must
be used to a project-based, problem-solving approach to learning. (Healy,
1998) They must also be willing to tolerate students progressing independently
and at varying paces. (Healy, 1998) Teachers need to understand that the
students may know more than they do and they should allow the students
to take on the role of the teachers. (Healy, 1998) Another way schools
can address these problems is to support innovators. (Healy, 1998) Teachers,
principals, or superintendents who understand the potential of technology
can help develop effective uses for it as well as gain resources by grant-writing
or other means. (Healy, 1998) Once teachers have gotten rid of some of
the deterrents to computer integration, they can begin to integrate computers
into the classroom. In the next section I will look at the ways computers
can be integrated into the classroom.
In English, the computer can be integrated into the curriculum during
the study of mass media. (Cobine, 1997) Students can read electronic newspapers
and magazines and take news quizzes with immediate answers. (Cobine, 1997)
They can also use the computer to write about political, social, and economic
events. (Cobine, 1997) The computer also can strengthen writing. (Cobine,
1997) In expository writing, students who need reference sources to support
their writing can extend their research through online encyclopedias,
periodicals, and libraries. (Cobine, 1997) In creative writing, students
can extend their collaborations through e-mail; they can correspond with
authors and illustrators, as well as experts on themes important to their
writing. (Cobine, 1997) In writing courses, the students could learn to
use a word processor, by typing proofreading, saving, and printing a previously
written paper. (Cobine, 1997) They could then move on to writing-in-progress
on the word processor. Also, in writing students can use a computer's
word processor to make instantaneous on-screen changes. (Cobine, 1997)
The instructor is also able to act like an editor than since the large
computer screen makes the writing legible to both. (Cobine, 1997) Instructors
can integrate the computer into a course gradually. (Cobine, 1997) Students
can began using the computer for min-research assignments and then use
it later on to do a research project. (Cobine, 1997) (Cobine, 1997) These
examples are just a few ways computers can be integrated into the classroom.
As I mentioned prior in my report computer integration is a hot topic.
Computers challenge some of our most deeply held beliefs on about how
children should be raised and educated. The common ground between those
who are for computers in the classroom and those who are against it is
the welfare of children. (Kehoe et al, 1997) Those of us who support have
computers in classrooms want to stretch the limits of education, put the
power of learning into the students hands and create a global village
where different cultures can come together. (Kehoe et al, 1997) We hope
that by establishing contact between our students and students of other
cultures that we will be able to find world peace. (Kehoe et al, 1997)
Those against have computers in the classrooms believe that stretching
the limits can be accomplished without computers in a variety of ways.
(Kehoe et al, 1997) Whether we have computers in classrooms or not, we
all need to understand that there is no easy fix to the problems with
education. Getting our school systems to meet the demands of the global
economy will not happen over night. It will take a lot of work from the
administrators, teachers, parents, and children.
Bibliography
1. Abdal Haqq, Ismat. (1995). "Infusing Technology into Preservice
Teacher Education." ERIC Digest. ED389699
2. AHA. (2002). Exercise (Physical Activity) and Children. American Heart
Association. http://216.185.112.5/presenter.jhtml?identifier=4596
3. Allen, Jeanne. (1994). A Primer on School Accountability. Center for
Education Reform.
http://edreform.com/pubs/account1.htm
4.
AOA. (2002). AOA Fact Sheets. American Obesity Organization. http://www.obesity.org/subs/fastfacts/aoafactsheets.shtml
5. Beck, Judy A.; Wynn, Harriet C. (1998). "Technology in Teacher
Education Progress Along the Continuum." ERIC Digest: ERIC Clearinghouse
on Teaching and Teacher Education in Washington D.C. ED 424212
6.
Blakey, Elaine; Spence, Sheila. (1990). "Developing Metacognition."
ERIC Digest. ERIC Clearinghouse on Information Resources. ED327218
7.
Bristow, Duane. (1997). Computer Literacy, Computer Skills, and Computer
Use in Schools and Small Businesses. http://www.webcom.com/duane/compeff.html
8.
Cobine, Gary R. (1997). "Studying with the Computer." ERIC Digest.
9.
CSULB. (1996) History, the History of Computers, and the History of Computers
in Education California State University, Long Beach. http://www.csulb.edu/~murdock/histofcs.html
10.
Darling-Hammond, Linda; Ascher, Carol. (1989). Creating Accountability
in Big City Schools. ERIC Clearinghouse of Urban Education
11.
Davis, Bernadette Caruso; Shade, Daniel D. (1994). "Integrate, Don't
Isolate Computers in the Early Childhood Curriculum." ERIC Digest.
ED 376991
12.
Dover, Kimeiko Hotta. (2002) Essential Computer Skills. Adult/Continuing
Education at About.com
13.
Encarta. (2001). Encarta World English Dictionary [North American Edition].
Microsoft Corporation.
14.
ERIC. (1983). "Microcomputers and Young Children." ERIC Digest:
Short Report ED327295
15.
Geisert, Paul; Futrell, Mygna. (1984). "Computer Literacy for Teachers."
ERIC Digest: ERIC Clearinghouse on Information Sources. ED 254210
16. Goldman, Shelley; Cole, Karen; Syer, Christina. (1999) The Technology/Content
Dilemma. Institute for Research of Learning: Menlo Park, CA. http://www.ed.gov/Technology/TechConf/1999/whitepapers/paper4.html
17. Hardin, Joseph; Ziebarth, John. (2000) Digital Technology and its
Impact on Education. National Center for Super Computing Applications:
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. http://www.ed.gov/Technology/Futures/hardin.html
18. Haugland, Susan W. (2000). "Computers and Young Children."
ERIC Digest: ERIC Clearinghouse on Elementary and Early Childhood Education.
ED438926
19. Healy, Jane, Ph.D. (1998). Failure to Connect: How Computers Affect
Our Children's Minds-for Better or Worse. New York: Simon and Schuster
20. Kahn, Jessica. (2000). One Computer Classroom. Chestnut Hill College:
Philadelphia
21. Kehoe, Brendan, and Mixon, Christopher. (1997). Children and the Internet:
A Zen Guide for Parents & Educators. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey:
Prentice Hall
22. LaMorte, Christopher, and Lilly, John. (1994). Computers History and
Development. Jones Telecommunications and Multimedia Encyclopedia. http://www.digitalcentury.com/encyclo/update/comp_hd.html
23. Learning Solutions. (1998). Strategies for the One Computer Classroom.
http://www.learnsol.com/onecompt.html
24. Moreno, Roxana; Mayer Richard E.; Spires, Hiller A.; Lester, James
C. (2001) "The Case for Social Agency in Computer Based Teaching
Do Students Learn More Deeply When They Interact with Animated Pedagogical
Agents?" Cognition and Instruction, 19(2), 177-213
25. NCES. (2000). Teachers Tools for the 21st Century. National Center
for Education Statistics.
http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2000/2000102C.pdf
26.
NSBA. (2002) Education Leadership Toolkit. National School Boards Foundation.
http://www.nsba.org/sbot/toolkit/index.html
27.
OLTCL. (1996). Teachers, Educational Computing and Professional Development.
Open Learning Technology Corporation Limited. http://www.educationau.edu.au/archives/cp/05.htm
28.
Papert, Seymour. (1993). The Children's Machine: Rethinking School in
the Age of the Computer. New York: Harper Collins
29. Stoll, Clifford. (1999). High Tech Heretic: Why Computers Don't Belong
in the Classroom and Other Reflections by a Computer Contrarian. New York:
Double Day
30.
Tan, Soo Boo. (1998). Using One Computer in the Classroom to Teach.
31. TLTI. (1999) Coaching Teachers at Different Skills Levels. Technology
Leadership Team Institute. North Central Regional Education Laboratory
http://www.ncrel.org/sdrs/thepoint/levels.htm
32. TRC. (2002) Writing in the One Computer Classroom. Technology Resource
Center: Seidel School of Information & Professional Studies. Salisbury
University. Salisbury, MD. http://trc.salisbury.edu/dm/computer.html
33.
University of Regina. (2002) Viruses, Trojan Horses, and Worms. Computer
Literacy Repository: University of Regina, Canada Computer Science Department
http://tdi.uregina.ca/~complit/viruses.htm
INTERNET RESOURCES FOR TEACHERS AND STUDENTS
KIDLINK
http://www.kidlink.org
KIDLINK is an international online organization for children grades Kindergarten-12th.
It offers KIDCAFE an online forum for children 10-15 in six languages
around the world. KIDLINK also offers mailing lists for educators and
parents and runs adult coordinator conferences.
Consortium
for School Networking (CoSN)
http://www.cosn.org
CoSN gives educators up-to-date information on how to get quick, easy,
and cost effective access to the Internet and online resources. It also
serves as a discussion list and sounding board for teachers, school administrators,
librarians, and other professionals involved in school networking.
Ask
ERIC
http://ericir.syr.edu
Ask Eric is an online question and answer service based on the Educational
Resources Information Center (ERIC) database at Syracuse University. It
also maintains a Virtual library and a Research & Development Department.
ERIC is a database of sixteen subject-specific clearinghouses.
Classroom
Connect
http://www.classroom.net
Classroom Connect is a hardcopy newsletter aimed at the K-12 online educator.
It is an easy way for educators and parents to gain information about
using technology in K-12 education. Classroom Connect also offers a list
serve for teachers and administrators to post questions and exchange information.
Cisco
Educational Archive and Resources Catalog Homepage (CEARCH)
http://sunsite.unc.edu/cisco/index.html
CEARCH contains the Virtual Schoolhouse, a meta-library of K-12 links,
an excellent research tool for K-12 educators and parents. The Virtual
Schoolhouse is divided into nine areas. "Classrooms" has educational
links sorted by subject, while "The Library" has links to libraries
and other sites where books can be found, and "The Art Room"
has links to museums and art exhibits. Games and entertainment can be
found at "The Playground." Teaching resources can be found in
the "Teachers Lounge" and administrative resources can be found
in "The Principal's Office."
U.S.
Department of Education
http://www.ed.gov
This site offers resources for teachers, administrators, and other people
involved in education.
International
Society for Technology in Education (ISTE)
http://www.iste.org/
This site offers teachers resources for using technology in the classroom
Edumatch
http://www.edumatch.com
This site offers educators free use of a search engine that allows them
to match state standards with over 4,000 educational software titles from
most of the educational software publishers in the United States.
Landmark
Project
http://landmarks4schools.org/
This site offers resources for assisting with the integration of curriculum
and technology. It also provides web tools for teachers including rubrics
and a template for seeking permission to use copyrighted materials for
classroom use.
PBS
Teachersource
http://www.pbs.org/teachersource/
This site offers over 1,400 pre-K through grade 12 lesson plans and activities
for curricular areas that include: Arts & Literature, Health &
Fitness, Math, Science & Technology, and Social Studies. Access to
program segments such as Nova, Frontline, The American Experience and
Sesame Street is also available.
WWW4Teachers
http://www.4teachers.org
This site is for teachers who are integrating technology into the curriculum.
It offers materials on internet safety, state standards, and technology
assessment. It also offers teacher tools like on-line note takers, quiz
makers, and rubric makers as well as professional development information.
NobleED
News
http://nobleednews.com
This site has material for parents, teachers, and students. Materials
for teachers include teaching strategies, state standards, lesson plans,
and student assessment materials. Parent material includes family activities,
parenting advice, and homework help. Student material is divided into
the areas of elementary, middle school, and high school and it has materials
appropriate for all three age groups.
Ditto.com
http://www.ditto.com
This site is a visual search engine that allows you to visually search
for pictures, information and products. You can search for pictures, images,
photos, information, products, clipart, fine art, etc.
MyGradebook.Com
http://mygradebook.com
This site allows teachers to create an online grade book and keep track
of grades on the Internet. It also allows parents and children to view
grading and attendance summaries with a password.
MARCO POLO
http://www.wcom.com/marcopolo
Marco Polo provides standards based internet content. Its resources include
panel-reviewed links to top sites in many disciplines, professionally
developed lesson plans, classroom activities, materials to help with daily
classroom planning, and powerful search engines.
The
Field Trips Site
http://www.field-trips.org/
Field Trips have virtual tours on nature topics as well as other topics.
Teacher's resources are included.
NEA
http://www.nea.org
This is the National Education Association website. It includes resources
for parents and educators, information on student achievement, as well
as articles about current issues in education.
Copernicus
Education Gateway
http://www.edgate.com
This is a site for teachers, parents, and students. It allows teachers
to create notes for homework and class information and post them on the
web for parents and students to access. It also offers search tools, activities
for students, and information on parenting issues.
Buddy
System Project
http://www.buddyproject.org
This site is designed for teachers, students, and parents. It offers sites
that are appropriate for each of these three groups. It also offers activities
for students, lessons that connect technology with classroom curriculum,
articles about using technology in the home as well as guidelines on how
to help students develop their searching strategies.
MagPortal.com
http://www.magportal.com
This is a search site that allows you to search for free magazine articles
on a variety of topics.
Blue
Web'N
http://www.kn.pacbell.com
Blue Web'n is an online library of 1200+ outstanding Internet sites categorized
by subject, grade level, and format (lessons, activities, projects, resources,
references, & tools).
An
Educator's Guide to Evaluating the Use of Technology in Schools and
Classrooms
http://www.ed.gov/pubs/EdTechGuide/
This site provides a handbook, complete with forms and sample surveys,
for the evaluation of your program.
COMPUTER SOFTWARE FOR SCHOOLS
Typing Master Typing Test
This is free keyboarding software. It offers typing games to help practice
typing skills, test texts to evaluate typing skills, personal test result
history and print out test diplomas.
GIMP
GIMP is an acronym for GNU Image Manipulation Program. It is free software
that can be used as a paint program, an expert quality photo retouching
program, an online batch processing system, a mass production image renderer,
and an image format converter.
KidPix
Studio
This is multimedia software with video, special effects and photos. Kids
can create slide show productions, QuickTime movies, and illustrate with
over 1,300 animated stamps.
Microsoft
Bookshelf 98
This is an all-purpose reference set. It includes a dictionary, thesaurus,
almanac, chronology, and computer dictionary.
Inspiration
This is software that helps students develop ideas and organize thinking.
It is ideal for use in language arts, science, social studies and research.
It assists students in brainstorming, planning, organizing, outlining,
prewriting, diagramming, concept mapping, and webbing.
PowerPoint
This is a presentation graphics program. It allows you to create presentations
and post them on the web.
Classbuilder
This is classroom management software. It allows teachers to create exams
and lesson plans. It also allows teachers to keep track of grades and
attendance.
Report
Cards Plus
This software allows schools to produce report cards and transcripts.
It also allows schools to generate honor roll, class rank, grade search,
and grade distribution reports.
EndNote
This is academic software that allows teachers and students to search
online bibliographic databases, organize their references, and create
bibliographies instantly and automatically.
Norton
Antivirus
This is virus protection software. It detects script-based threats, scans
and cleans outgoing e-mail messages to prevent sending infected files
from your PC. Automatic Live Update checks for and installs new virus
definitions when you're connected to the Internet to keep your system
updated against the latest viruses
|